This post contains affiliate links which means that I will make a small commission if you purchase a product after clicking on any of them, at no extra cost to you.
Let’s be real—the best part of mornings (besides coffee, obviously) is a warm, fresh bagel loaded with all the good stuff. I’ve been on a serious mission to track down the best bagels in Tampa, and let me tell you—it did not disappoint. So grab your coffee, and let’s get into the cream (cheese) of the crop!
Best Bagels in Tampa
1. Pete’s
If you want bagels with both style and substance, Pete’s Bagels in Ybor City is the spot. This isn’t just your average bagel shop—it’s got a chill coffee shop vibe, a sunny patio, and even a dog park area for the ultimate laid-back hangout.
My go-to? The “Millennial Pete”—a bagel masterpiece loaded with creamy avocado and zesty pickled red onions. Every bite is a flavor explosion!
Oh, and Pete’s isn’t just about bagels—they’ve got freshly baked pastries, great coffee (it’s one of the best coffee shops in Ybor!), and a cozy atmosphere that makes it impossible to leave.
2. Willa’s Provisions
Another Tampa coffee shop that absolutely delivers on the bagel game is Willa’s Provisions. As soon as I walk in, I know I’m about to be treated to some insanely good bagels with their homemade scallion and chive cream cheese.
Want to level up your bagel experience? Try one of their bagel boards—you can’t go wrong with veggie, salmon, or chicken salad toppings! It’s the kind of spread that makes your brunch dreams come true.
3. Sesame
Tucked away in Hyde Park, Sesame brings something totally unique to Tampa’s bagel scene. While it’s not my top pick for a classic bagel, Sesame is the only place in town where you can get the iconic rainbow bagel—so if you’re looking for something fun and Insta-worthy, this is it!
But here’s the real kicker—Sesame turns into a Tampa speakeasy at night! If you make a reservation, you’ll get access to this exclusive hidden bar, by giving them a secret bagel order. Talk about a bagel adventure with a twist!
4. The Lab
With its sleek, industrial vibe, The Lab Coffee is the perfect place to post up with your laptop—but let’s be real, we’re here for the bagels.
Their breakfast bagel sandwich is next level, especially with a side of Sriracha mayo that takes it up a notch. Pair that with great coffee and a cool atmosphere, and it’s easy to see why this spot belongs on every bagel lover’s list.
They’ve now got two locations—one near downtown Tampa and another in Seminole Heights. If you’re in the area, it’s worth checking out some of the best coffee shops in Seminole Heights while you’re at it!
5. Moxie’s Cafe
For bagel sandwiches and some of the best cold brew in Tampa, Moxie’s Cafe is a solid go-to.
My order? The Breakfast Melt—a fluffy scrambled egg, gooey American cheese, and a perfectly toasted NY-style bagel. But next time, I’ve got my eye on the Asiago Garden Bagel, and I already know it’s going to be a winner.
If you’re looking for a no-frills, consistently great bagel, Moxie’s should be on your radar.
6. Graze 1910
If you’re a fan of comfort food, Graze 1910 has you covered. This spot knows how to do breakfast right, and their bagel sandwiches are no exception.
The B-Y-O-Brunchwich is an absolute standout—two eggs, melty cheese, and your choice of protein on a perfectly toasted everything bagel. Easily one of the best breakfast sandwiches in Tampa. And let’s not forget about the tater tots on the side—crispy, golden, and impossible to resist.
For something a little lighter, their everything bagel with dill schmear or the salmon and bagel with smoked salmon, dill schmear, scallion, and pickled onion are also solid picks.
7. Psomi
Bringing a Greek twist to the Tampa bagel scene, Psomi is a spot that always delivers on fresh flavors and high-quality ingredients.
Their golden-brown bagels are simple yet packed with Mediterranean charm. Choose from everything, cinnamon raisin, plain, or sesame bagels, and pair it with whipped cream cheese, Le Meunier butter, or house-made jam. It’s a refreshing take on a breakfast staple, and it’s worth every bite.
8. Victory Coffee
If you’re searching for a classic, no-fuss bagel done right, Victory Coffee has you covered. Sure, their coffee is top-tier, but let’s be real—the bagels are the real MVP here.
Their bagel sandwiches are made fresh in their scratch kitchen, and while they stick to tried-and-true classics, they absolutely nail the execution. Made-to-order, packed with flavor, and always on point—this is the kind of place that keeps you coming back for more.
9. Marlene’s Original Breakfast Sandiwich
Okay, I’ll admit—I didn’t get my breakfast sandwich on a bagel here (they were out for the day, tragic), but that’s not stopping me from giving Marlene’s Original Breakfast Sandwich the shoutout it deserves.
They’ve got breakfast sandwiches down to a science, with a lineup of proteins, veggies, and sauces that take your morning meal to the next level.
We went for the #1 “Marlene’s Way” and the #4 “Fully Loaded”—and while both were packed with flavor, the maple drizzle on #4 sealed the deal for me. That sweet and salty combo? Absolute magic. With so many options on the menu, I have no doubt they’re all absolute winners.
Are you ready to experience the best bagels in Tampa?
At this point, I know your list of bagel spots to try is getting dangerously long—but trust me, every one of these is worth it. Whether you’re into simple, classic bagels or loaded breakfast sandwiches, Tampa delivers.
So which of these bagels in Tampa are you running to first? Because I might just be right there with you!
Before you go be sure to follow @sunkissedintampa_ on Instagram and check out some other Tampa blog posts:
Awesome breweries in Seminole Heights
Fun things to do in Seminole Heights
Leave a Reply